My buyer defaulted in month nine and the Indianapolis market had moved enough that I came out fine, but the note structure was the reason and not the equity
Bought the note back from myself essentially, is how I think about it now. Sold a duplex off of Meridian in late 2021, carried 80 percent of the purchase price at 6.5 on a five year balloon with a 25 year am schedule, and when the buyer stopped paying in September of 2022 I had two options sitting in front of me. Wait out a full Indiana foreclosure, which was going to take me into early 2024 at minimum, or negotiate a deed in lieu and hand him something small to walk. I offered $4,500 to walk clean, he took it, and I had the deed back inside 60 days. The property had appreciated about $31,000 from the sale price. I sold it again in spring of 2023 for more than the original note balance plus what I paid him to leave. What made that work was the 20 percent down I required upfront. Without that equity cushion sitting behind him, the math on the deed in lieu conversation changes completely because he has nothing to lose by dragging it out. I see people carrying paper on five and ten percent down and I understand why they do it, the deal closes and the monthly check looks good, but the down payment is not the buyer showing good faith, it is the mechanism that makes a voluntary exit possible when things go wrong. That is the whole job it does.