Does a master lease structure on a 55-plus deal protect the equity or just move the occupancy risk somewhere less visible
A deal worth studying: 96 units, active adult, stabilized at 91 percent, operator proposes a master lease at a fixed rent of $142,000 a month. At that rent the buyer sees a 6.1 cap on purchase price. The operator takes the upside if occupancy climbs and absorbs the downside if it falls, at least on paper. The question is whether the fixed rent is set low enough that the operator keeps meaningful upside at any realistic occupancy, which means the buyer traded volatility for a cap rate that already has the risk priced out of it.
The structure I keep trying to work through is what happens in month 14 when occupancy slips to 83 percent. The master lease still pays. The equity still looks stable. But the operator is now burning cash on the gap between collected rent and the fixed obligation, and if that continues they either renegotiate or they go, and at that point the buyer owns a 83-percent-occupied active adult building with no operator and a lender who financed a stabilized asset. The master lease did not remove the occupancy risk, it just delayed when the buyer sees it.
The cap rate on a direct-operated deal with the same building might price at 6.4 or 6.5 on current income, and the buyer retains the upside if the waitlist holds. Whether that 30 to 40 basis point spread is fair compensation for taking operating exposure directly depends almost entirely on how deep the operator's balance sheet is behind the master lease guarantee, which is the document almost nobody reads before LOI.
What does the guarantee actually look like on the master lease deals you have seen, personal guarantee, corporate guarantee with a thin entity behind it, or something with real assets pledged?