Should I be rekeying between every guest stay or just after a tenant moves out
We swapped to smart locks on the Pickett cabin about fourteen months ago and I genuinely stopped thinking about this problem for a while. New code per guest, rotates automatically, done. But my partner owns a lake unit two counties over that still runs a physical deadbolt, and after a twelve-night stay ended in March we just changed the code on the lockbox and moved on. Somebody finally asked us whether that was enough and I did not have a clean answer.
The thing that made me actually look at this: a guest in February left and then pinged us four days later saying she thought she left a charger. She still had the door code. She was a fine guest and probably was not going back in there, but she could have. That was a $340 two-night booking and the next guest checked in 36 hours after she left.
For a full tenant situation, so a 30-plus-day stay, I think you just rekey. Every time. That person had a key in hand, possibly made a copy, definitely had time to. The $50 or whatever a locksmith charges in Fentress County is not the number that should stop you. The number that stopped me from doing it sooner was friction, not cost. I did not have a locksmith I trusted near the property and I kept putting it off.
Short guest stays feel different because the exposure window is smaller, but I am not sure the logic actually holds. A motivated person can copy a key overnight. We are moving the lake unit to a smart lock this summer specifically because I do not want to keep having this conversation with myself every checkout.