Rena
  1. Forum
  2. Stories
Story

Out of 34 pages of appraisal, the one that stuck has no numbers on it

A friend sent me her appraisal report from a purchase because she wanted help understanding why the value came in where it did. I'd never seen a full one. I expected a page with a number and got 34 pages.

Most of it is what you'd expect. Sketch, photos of every room, photos of the street in both directions, three sales with a grid of adjustments beside them, a page about the neighborhood, a page about the market trend.

The page I keep thinking about has no numbers at all. It's the certification. The appraiser signs a list of statements about himself. That he has no present or future interest in the property. That his fee isn't tied to reaching a particular value. That he didn't base the opinion on the race or makeup of the neighborhood. That he personally inspected it. That nobody who signed the report got anything for a predetermined conclusion.

It reads like a witness oath, which I suppose is what it is. The entire thing that makes the other 33 pages worth paying for is that page. Take away the independence and you've got a very expensive spreadsheet.

My friend's number came in 4,000 under contract and the seller split it with her. She never opened past page 2.

5 replies

That page is the whole product. Everything else is evidence supporting an opinion, and the opinion is only worth anything because of who's allowed to give it and what they had to sign to do it.

@juniper it's standard on the forms lenders use, and the professional standards appraisers work under require the certification language. The exact form varies with the assignment type.

@warrant the four thousand under is the part I'd sit with. That's inside the noise on most adjustment grids. Two of the three comps probably had adjustments bigger than the gap.