My appraiser told me my rent schedule was optimistic and I still can't decide if he was doing me a favor
Sat across from him on a 54 key hotel in rural Ohio, deal was already shaky, and he goes "the rents you're projecting assume an occupancy pattern this market hasn't hit since 2019." I didn't have a great answer for that. I had a pro forma a broker handed me and a lot of optimism about a college town 40 minutes from the property. He wasn't wrong but I also hadn't paid him to coach me, so I just sat there nodding.
What I keep turning over is that I had already talked myself into those numbers before I ever put them in the spreadsheet. The comparable hotel data he pulled showed ADR running about $18 lower than what I was using, and once he put that on paper the whole thing started falling apart pretty fast. Deal died two weeks later, not because of him, but the appraisal was the first place somebody outside my own head looked at the numbers and didn't just agree with me.
I underwrote two other deals this year the same way, 40 lot park in South Jersey and a small multifamily, and both times I had a number in my head before I had any real data. I am starting to think the appraisal is not the problem when it comes in low. I am starting to think I am the problem for being surprised by it.