Discussion
I'm under contract on a 6-bed rooming house in west Phoenix, $389k ask, and my hard money lender's guy put it at $371k. I went into the MLS myself and found four sales within a ha…
Discussion
Someone put it to me this way this week: the buy price feels like the risk, but the appraisal date is where the deal actually passes or fails. That landed differently than I expec…
Story
A deal worth studying: an REO priced at 94k in a market where the three closest sold comps averaged 108k. On paper that is a 14k margin before a single nail. The appraisal the ban…
Win
I have been running numbers on two-family and three-family capes in West Roxbury for about eight months. The ones I keep almost buying are priced somewhere between $750k and $900k…
Discussion
A seller considering a carryback has a real incentive problem. They want the value high enough to justify the price, which means the appraisal they commission before listing is wo…
Happening Now
That number stuck with me because the fund had been marketing 10.5% net and a 68% LTV on that position, so either the appraisal was fiction or the exit timing turned a performing…
Discussion
I've been sitting with this question for about three months now. There's a three-over-one on Jefferson in a mid-size market I won't name yet, asking price implying a 6.2 cap blend…
Win
Bought it for a client relocating from the Bay Area, $2.1M, single family on about an acre, and the comp situation was genuinely thin because nothing comparable had sold in that p…
Discussion
I am watching a duplex in Garfield Heights that is listed at $189,000 and I have been running numbers on it for about six weeks. My concern is not whether I can get to the down pa…
Happening Now
A construction lender orders an as-completed appraisal before the first dollar moves, and that number sets the loan ceiling. The problem surfaces at draw three or four, when the a…
Happening Now
Looking at a deal in Cincinnati, $4.2M stabilized retail strip, senior lender has a full appraisal in at $4.05M, sponsor is asking me to come in at $380K mezz between the senior a…
Happening Now
A deal worth studying: purchase at 210k, ARV appraised at 340k after a 55k renovation, two-year hold with a spring list. The appraiser pulled three comps averaging 345k, which sup…
Discussion
Came up in conversation with another passive investor I know and figured this room might have thoughts from the other side of it. Cash wasn't fully on the table but the buyer had…
Happening Now
A deal worth studying: the contract is at 2.95M, the buyer's lender accepts the first appraisal at 2.91M, both sides proceed, then the buyer switches lenders at week six and the n…
Happening Now
I have two rural parcels I want to borrow against and the lender keeps asking about income documentation. Those are land, so fine. But I've been looking at a 16-room house in a co…
Discussion
I have been thinking about this because the two methods can produce meaningfully different conclusions on the same property, and the appraiser's selection is rarely explained in t…
Happening Now
I'm looking at a deal where the entire return model depends on what the property appraises at after rehab, and the operator is the one who built the projection. He's citing comps…
Discussion
I am sitting in second position on a Columbus rehab, $47k in, and the senior did a full appraisal at the start of the draw schedule. My attorney says I can rely on that report for…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a small commercial building on a lot zoned for a higher-density use, under contract at $480,000. The seller priced it on income from the existing structure.…
Happening Now
I am trying to figure this out because I have a 47 acre parcel I am looking at about two hours from me and the seller is saying part of the value is standing timber, maybe 18 to 2…
Discussion
A detached 480 square foot cottage, built for $210,000 all in, appraised at $137,000 on completion. On paper that looks like a destruction of equity. But the owner had purchased t…
Discussion
That gap is not abstract. If the contract was at 3.1M and the appraisal lands at 2.91M, a 65 percent loan against the appraised value puts the lender at 1.89M. If the original und…
Happening Now
A case worth sitting with: a 34,000 square foot center, purchase price 4.1 million, anchor at 8,200 square feet paying $11.40 per foot. The lease has a five-year renewal option at…
Happening Now
Here is a situation worth working through. Take the T12 from a listing broker on a 14 unit in Akron and rebuild it independently. The buyer's number comes out at 94k NOI against a…
Happening Now
Here is a pattern from the valuation side that deserves more attention from buyers. Go back through a year of appraisal files on retail centers and it is not unusual to find that…
Happening Now
I'm looking at pulling cash out of my condo, maybe $40k, and my loan officer mentioned something about a waiver being possible depending on LTV. I'm at roughly 58% LTV right now s…
Discussion
This is worth walking through as an illustration. An operator underwrites a duplex to a 187,000 ARV on the strength of a comp that closed at 191,000 in April 2023. The refinance a…
Discussion
Bought a condo in Denver's Sloan's Lake area in early 2023 for $410k. Put about $38k into it, kitchen, primary bath, new flooring throughout, finished out a small storage room int…
Win
Take a single family bought at 71k with 38k of rehab put into it, refinanced at 121k on a DSCR loan at 7.1 percent six months in. That returns 103k of the 109k the operator had in…
Happening Now
Say a buyer is under contract on a 1,280 square foot house on 6 acres in a county with maybe 90 arms length sales a year. Contract price 148k, cash out purchase money loan behind…
Discussion
Two numbers in this room don't fit together for me. A single family appraisal is $300 to $600, and AVMs or property condition reports already sit on something like 35 to 45 percen…
Poll
I've been sitting in on vendor demos for the new UAD format, the one in broad production since January with mandatory use coming November 2 this year, and I can't work out which d…
Happening Now
Here is a scenario worth pricing out. A rural investor's county and two adjoining ones are covered by one certified residential appraiser. He is 63. Turn times on lender orders ru…
Loss
Consider a small older four unit building, all two bed units, under contract at $560,000, where the appraisal comes back at $489,000 and the loan dies on it. Costs like the apprai…
Discussion
Duplex, contract at $410,000, lender ordered a 1025. There's a converted garage unit that's been rented at $1,400 a month for years, no permit on file, separate meter, own entranc…
Happening Now
First purchase, small 3 bedroom, and I have three numbers in front of me that don't agree. The county assessor site says 218,400. Zillow says 291,000. The accepted offer is 279,00…
Poll
Running the numbers on next year's mix for a small valuation practice, the two paths do not compare cleanly, so it helps to lay out both. Panel work through management companies p…
Win
Land parcel, 68 acres, mostly wooded with about 11 acres of cleared pasture and a gravel access easement. County reassessed it and moved the value up 41 percent in one cycle, whic…
Happening Now
Consider a small pool of seasoned second liens. Twenty two loans, unpaid balances from 18k to 96k, weighted average coupon 9.4, seasoning of 14 to 31 months, seller asking 88 of U…
Discussion
House is under contract at $332,000, buyer's lender ordered the appraisal, it came back $314,000. Two of the three comps the appraiser used are older houses with original kitchens…
Win
Here is a program worth studying for anyone buying small second liens in the $30k to $90k balance range. The common starting practice is to take whatever value sits in the seller'…
Discussion
I'm a few deals in and my ceiling right now is that I can't tell a good number from a hopeful one fast enough. Two people have suggested I get an appraisal license so I stop payin…
Happening Now
Take a duplex, both sides 2/1, bought 26 months ago at 318k with roughly 71k put into it since: new roof, both kitchens, a full electrical rework, exterior paint, a rebuilt rear s…
Happening Now
Consider an appraiser who took on a trainee last August. Most states require supervised hours before a trainee can sign independently, and the hour count and co-signature rules va…
Discussion
Take an owner who finished 900 square feet of basement, permitted, with an egress window and proper heat, in a house that shows 1,600 above grade. The appraisal comes back describ…
Happening Now
Take a residential appraisal firm in a mid-size metro that's for sale. Two certified residential appraisers, both owners, one trainee about 700 hours into supervised experience. A…
Poll
Second offer accepted this month and the loan officer came back with a waiver from the automated underwriting run, so no appraisal ordered, no fee, and the file moves faster. She…
Poll
First appraisal I've ever watched happen start to finish. Small three bedroom, nothing unusual about it, lender ordered it for a purchase. The appraiser arrived, walked every room…
Loss
Wanted to get into valuation work. Found the qualifying education requirement for a trainee credential in my state, signed up for the package, paid $3,100 up front for the courses…
Poll
Someone reached out about doing property data collection for hybrid reports. I go out, measure, photograph to a standard, upload it, and a licensed appraiser I never meet writes t…
Poll
Finishing a full gut on a three bed in an older neighborhood and I'm arguing with myself about spending $500 before it goes on the market. The case for ordering one: my comps are…