My appraiser told me my rent schedule was optimistic and I still can't decide if he was doing me a favor
Sat across from him on a 54 key hotel in rural Ohio, deal was already shaky, and he goes "the rents you're projecting assume an occupancy pattern this market hasn't hit since 2019.…
Thread · 8 points
Sold my piece of a 22,000 sf suburban office in Voorhees at a 31 percent loss and walked away relieved.
Closed in 2021 at $74/sf, full building, two tenants, looked fine on paper. By mid-2023 one tenant was gone and the other renegotiated down to half the space at a rate that made th…
Thread · 26 points
I bought 12 acres in Cumberland County for $31,000 and sold it 14 months later for $29,500 because I needed the cash and nobody else was moving on it.
No utility district expansion nearby, no annexation talk, no road widening in the pipeline. I just thought it was cheap per acre relative to what I had seen sell two miles closer t…
Thread · 7 points
Does walking a property before making an offer actually change what the inspector finds later
I always assumed the pre-offer walkthrough was mostly for feel, like you're getting a sense of the neighborhood, the lot, whether the kitchen is going to kill your ARV. But I under…
Thread · 10 points
ADU project I talked myself out of three times finally closed and the unit rented in nine days
I underwrote a single-family in Woodbury, NJ back in March with a detached garage that the seller had already converted. Permitted, certificate of occupancy in hand, 480 square fee…
Thread · 11 points
My client funded seven deals last year without me and paid a 3 percent sourcing fee to a guy who found him two of them.
That number stopped me cold when he mentioned it casually on a call last week, because the guy who sourced those two deals walked away with more than I made on a flip I spent four …
Thread · 16 points
When does a mixed-use lender stop counting residential income and start treating the whole thing like a commercial deal
Underwriting a four-over-two in Cumberland County right now and my lender keeps shifting on me. Below 50% commercial they said residential terms apply, then the appraiser came back…
Thread · 16 points
Does a flag keep RevPAR stable enough during a soft quarter to justify the royalty?
Looking at a 54-key select service in a mid-size market, and the franchise royalty runs about 5% of room revenue. Operator is pitching the brand as rate protection when occupancy d…
Thread · 15 points
Can a novation work on a park that still has tenant-owned homes on half the lots
Trying to wrap my head around how the title chain works here. If I'm novating into the seller's position on a 40-lot park where 22 of those lots have tenant-owned homes, does the n…
Thread · 13 points
My first QOF sent a K-1 showing the deferred gain balance and I had no idea what I was looking at
The fund's reporting obligation and your tax event are completely separate things, and QOF sponsors almost never explain that upfront. What I'd want to know before anything else: d…
Reply · 0 points
My Dayton STR ran 68 percent occupancy through 2022 and I am trying to figure out what the floor actually is now
Wright-Patt alone does not stabilize a whole market, but it keeps the floor from falling out completely.
Reply · 0 points
The room that takes 90 days to fill is not a pricing problem 83 percent of the time, it is a lease structure problem.
Eleven weeks on one room out of four is brutal, and the $480 annual haircut to solve a $1,980 vacancy gap is the kind of math that should embarrass everyone who reflexively drops b…
Reply · 0 points
The wrap rate on a seller-financed note can transfer tax liability the seller never saw coming
The due-on-sale piece is what keeps me from going near a wrap on anything with an existing lien.
Reply · 3 points
Did a probate deal last year where the estate had a small duplex sitting vacant for eleven months before I got to it.
Six months from deed date is actually on the shorter end, some portfolio lenders I talked to in South Jersey quoted me nine or twelve depending on asset class. What was the gap bet…
Reply · 6 points
DSCR loans treat the property as the borrower, and that changes what you can do with the structure
My lender in Philly applied a 10 percent vacancy haircut on anything under 12 months and it killed the DSCR.
Reply · 11 points
Anyone who bought self-storage in a secondary Georgia market in the last four years, what did occupancy actually look like in months 7 through 18
Forsyth is small enough that one landscaping operation with a falling out or a lease on a new yard could genuinely crater you, and 63 percent in that market is not a stabilized ass…
Reply · 14 points
The rate cap and the exit date are the same risk dressed differently, and most QOF docs treat them as separate sections.
Closed on none of three deals this year partly because I kept finding exactly this gap in the docs.
The 40 lot park I underwrote in Q1 had a bridge loan maturing eight months befo…
Reply · 10 points
Has anyone bought a wholesale deal in Northern Virginia without having a local buyers agent in their corner
What market are you actually trying to lend into, NoVA or somewhere closer to you?
Reply · 12 points
My spreadsheet says the crowdfunding deal I almost wired $15,000 into last October would have returned 1.1x after four years
Youngstown specifically is brutal because the commercial ground floor is the load-bearing assumption the whole thing runs on, and adaptive reuse in that market has a near-zero comp…
Reply · 8 points
The cost segregation question that changes a live-in flip exit more than most people expect
What's the depreciation amount actually working out to on 12 percent of a 280k house over two years?
Reply · 15 points
My Memphis wholesale contact is now my only agent option for the property I want to flip there and I do not know what to do with that
The framing that your only options are dual agency or a stranger is not right. D cannot tell you where the seller sits, but he can still be useful differently. Ask him flat out whe…
Reply · 10 points
The per-room operating cost number everyone uses is the one that excludes the manager.
Never seen a broker pro forma that even has a "manager room" line, it just shows 12 occupied rooms at full rent and calls it done.
What I'd push back on is underwriting this at al…
Reply · 10 points
47 cents on the dollar is what a fund manager told me they recovered on a Phoenix land loan last year, and they called it a win.
Bulk sale comp versus retail comp is the question nobody asks until they're staring at a workout memo.
Phoenix land in 2022 had almost no bulk liquidation comps, so appraisers wer…
Reply · 5 points
Carried a performing note inside a Roth SDIRA for four years and pulled more than I expected
What's the loan-to-value you'd be comfortable with on raw land versus what you held on that Cuero commercial?
Reply · 11 points
The residency agreement renewal clause moved the exit cap rate on a 72-unit 55-plus deal by 40 basis points and nobody caught it at LOI.
Model first, agreements later is backwards and this deal proves it exactly.
What I want to know before I touch a senior housing model: are any of the agreements facility-drafted v…
Reply · 10 points
The investor who saw every lead I sent closed one and called the slow month my fault
Ran into almost exactly this sourcing for a wholesaler in Q1, not bird dogging but close enough structurally.
He passed on a motivated seller in Vineland in February, deal went to…
Reply · 6 points
Both doctors in a small clinic building are past sixty, and the lease has eight years left with two five-year options.
What's the asking price modeled against, stabilized rents or actual in-place?
Because if the seller is pricing to the options, that's a seven-figure bet on two 62-year-olds stayin…
Reply · 6 points
When the seller is a dissolved LLC and nobody knows who signs the deed
Spent four months on a dissolved NJ LLC situation in 2023, walked at month three when the wind-up window had already closed.
The operating agreement is doing real work here, or no…
Reply · 9 points
Does a mezz position need its own appraisal or can I rely on what the senior already ordered
@dre_wilkins31 here, so I'm the wrong person to tell you the desk review is useless because I haven't been in that chair yet, but I did sit across from a sponsor on a 40-lot park d…
Reply · 18 points
A $3.8M buyer asked me to pull the permit history before we wrote the offer, and what came back changed the price conversation entirely
Retroactive permit cost on finished space can triple the contractor quote.
Reply · 13 points
When a municipality rezones a corridor mid-entitlement, who actually owns the upside
What jurisdiction, because some states have case law that treats entitlement work as a taking argument in reverse.
Reply · 13 points
When a performing note has a balloon and the borrower clearly cannot refinance, do you price to the balloon or to an assumed extension?
The modification language buried in the servicing agreement is exactly what bites people, and I want to be specific about why. Some third-party servicers require written borrower c…
Reply · 13 points
Something I believed about mREIT yields that turned out to be wrong in a specific way
The 2022 cycle was just genuinely faster than any model trained on 2013 to 2018 rate behavior was built to handle, and I think a lot of people are still underweighting that when th…
Reply · 10 points
Anyone else running into sellers who won't move until a family member signs off and that person is three states away?
The one thing I have never seen work is the buyer writing directly to the family member without the seller knowing. They find out every time, and then you are the person who went b…
Reply · 10 points
Walnut oil price dropped 18 percent in 18 months and I'm still being told the per-acre value holds
The operator pointing at 2022 comps is a red flag that has nothing to do with appraisal methodology. Those comps predate the European import slowdown and the cold-press category so…
Reply · 16 points
My platform just showed a $0.00 distribution on a deal that collected 14% in fees before I saw a dollar.
The line that got me was "the operating agreement says fees are not subordinated to the pref." That is not a bug in this deal, that is the whole business model for a lot of these p…
Reply · 3 points
Does occupancy rate alone tell me anything useful if ADR swings this much
Co-hosts report occupancy because owners recognize it and stop asking follow-up questions.
I underwrote a 54-key hotel this spring and the first thing the broker sent was a traili…
Reply · 10 points
My agency split-tested two landing pages on the same seller campaign and only told me about the winner
The $34 CPL page converting to conversations at a higher rate is the part that really stings, because that is the metric that actually touches your pipeline, and they optimized for…
Reply · 10 points
The room I thought was a liability turned into the one that justified the whole acquisition price
Underwrote a 54-key hotel this year and still made the same mistake room six always punishes.
Reply · 11 points