The wrap rate on a seller-financed note can transfer tax liability the seller never saw coming
Someone walked me through a sale they closed eighteen months ago where they held a first at six percent and wrapped a new note to the buyer at nine. The spread looked like income. What they had not modeled was that the IRS treats the full face amount of the wrap as the sale price for installment purposes, and the interest component on the overlapping balances gets allocated in a way that pushed ordinary income higher than they expected, while the capital gain piece shrank. The numbers still worked, but the tax picture was about thirty percent worse than their back-of-envelope showed going in. The assumption doing the most work was that the spread was just yield. It was also a recharacterization event sitting inside the note structure. A straight carry on a free-and-clear property does not have this problem, so the wrap is not inherently wrong, but it needs a CPA who has actually modeled a wrap before closing, not after. The other thing worth naming is that if the underlying loan has a due-on-sale clause and the lender calls it, the wrap collapses and the seller is suddenly holding a buyer who cannot perform and a lender demanding payoff at the same time. That sequence has ended sales in foreclosure where the seller thought they were the protected party. So my question for anyone who has sold on a wrap: did you price the underlying lender risk into the rate, or did the spread come from somewhere else?