The 60 percent rent roll shift from one tenant decision is the core thing suburban office does that multi-family and industrial do not, and it is structural rather than bad luck. With two tenants in 22,000 sf you had no diversification. Each tenant represented a binary event, and that is true of most suburban office in that size range regardless of credit quality or lease term at acquisition.
The assumption doing the most work at $74/sf in 2021 was lease continuity. Suburban office underwriting that year was almost universally discounting re-leasing risk, because the prior cycle had not stress-tested what happens when hybrid work becomes a CFO line item. The building's physical condition was irrelevant once that CFO decision landed. The rent roll was the asset, and you effectively had a two-stock concentrated position.
The capital call dynamic is worth naming. Passing was a rational response to the information available at the time, but the dilution from 6.1 to 4.4 meant you absorbed the full proportional loss on a smaller equity base while also having funded the original acquisition. That is a compounding structure on the downside that syndication documents often bury in the dilution mechanics. A licensed attorney needs to review those provisions before you enter any future syndication.
The risk you did not mention is that this outcome is not specific to Voorhees or to 2021 vintage. Suburban office in the 15,000 to 50,000 sf range with one or two tenants carries this binary exposure regardless of market. The bifurcation in office right now is partly about asset class and partly about tenant count and lease structure, and the two are correlated. Smaller suburban product tends to have thinner tenant diversification by definition.
One thing worth thinking through before the next deal: what is your actual tolerance for a capital call, and how does that interact with the dilution mechanics in a typical GP/LP structure?