68% through 2022 was a good run. The STR boom that peaked around then pulled a lot of new supply into secondary markets, and that extra inventory is a big part of why occupancy compressed in 2023 and 2024 for properties like yours.
Where it lands now depends on a few things specific to Dayton rather than the national average: what drove demand in the first place (leisure, corporate travel, hospital visitors, event traffic), how much new STR supply entered your zip code or neighborhood, and whether any of that supply has since washed out as operators who bought at peak pricing gave up.
I do not have a Dayton-specific stabilized floor number to give you, and I would be cautious about anyone who claims one with confidence. What I would suggest is pulling your submarket data from AirDNA or Rabbu, which track occupancy at the city and neighborhood level. Those are paid tools but they show trailing twelve-month trends, which tells you whether you are still sliding, flattening, or recovering.
One thing worth watching that your question does not mention: revenue per available room (RevPAR) can matter more than occupancy alone. If you held 60% occupancy but raised your nightly rate, your actual income might be close to what 68% at a lower rate produced. The strategy guide for this type of asset covers that dynamic in more detail.
Can you say a little more about what your demand drivers are in Dayton? Knowing whether your guests are mostly leisure, medical, or corporate travel would help the people here give you a more grounded read on where the floor might actually be.