Vacant possession sounds like a gift until you count what it actually costs to hold.
A 16-unit sitting fully vacant at closing transfers cleanly, no estoppels, no inherited leases, no tenant attorneys holding the schedule hostage. That is the whole appeal. Take a building at 1.2 million with operating expenses running around 8,400 a month once taxes, insurance and utilities are carried by the owner. At 60 days to place a buyer and another 90 days before the buyer stabilizes enough to refinance out, that is roughly 42,000 in dead carry before a single rent check clears. Buyers know this, and they price it. The building I am describing trades at a bigger discount than a stabilized comparable, which is obvious, but the spread between what sellers expect and what buyers actually underwrite for vacant product is wider than most sellers believe going in, and that gap lands on the assignment fee.
The more interesting problem is that vacancy does not compress all buyer types equally. A syndicator who needs to show projected income to close a raise is far more penalized by vacancy than a family office writing a check with no equity partners to manage. The same building, the same numbers, can clear an assignment fee or kill it depending entirely on which pocket the capital is coming from.
So the question I want the room to answer is this: when you tie up a vacant or near-vacant commercial property, do you price your assignment fee off what a stabilized building would trade at and work backward from there, or do you treat the vacancy discount as the floor and fee off the buyer's upside once the building performs?