Owner-built homes in mid-construction are some of the hardest collateral I see priced accurately
A family spent four years and $190,000 cash framing and roughing in a 2,400 square foot house on land they own free and clear. No permits pulled on the addition they added in year two. No certificate of occupancy because the building is maybe 65 percent complete. They need $80,000 to finish it and they have been turned down by three banks, which is exactly what you would expect, because a conventional lender cannot appraise an incomplete structure against comparable sales. The assumption doing the most work in every denial is the as-is value, and right now that value is genuinely ambiguous. A finished home of that size in their county might be worth $420,000. An incomplete one with an unpermitted addition is worth whatever a cash buyer would pay for a complicated project, which could be $180,000 or $140,000 depending on the day and who is looking. That spread is where the lending problem lives. A private lender sizing a first position note here is not really lending against a house. They are lending against a construction timeline, a permit resolution, and an owner-builder's ability to finish what they started, all wrapped in collateral that cannot be conventionally financed out at payoff. The exit is the problem. If the borrower finishes and pulls a CO, a conventional cash-out refi at $420,000 appraised value covers the private note easily, and the lender gets paid in full. If the permit issue stalls, the lender is sitting on a note secured by a property that still cannot be refinanced. Points and rate do not fix a bad exit, they just make the yield look better while you wait for the problem to resolve. The structure I would want to see is staged draws tied to permit milestones, not to construction progress alone, with the first draw contingent on a confirmed permit resolution path from the county in writing. The land value alone needs to cover at minimum the first draw at a reasonable LTV before any money moves. What is the permit situation on the unpermitted addition, and has the county indicated whether they will require it to be torn out or brought up to code?