Softness in Class B rent growth is showing up in suburban portfolios but the concession structure is hiding it from the headline numbers
A deal worth studying: 280 units, suburban Atlanta, B-minus vintage, asking effective rents flat to prior year. The in-place leases show $1,420 average asking rent. Net effective rent after one month free on a 12-month lease is $1,302. The broker deck uses $1,420. The trailing rent roll uses $1,420. The T-12 NOI uses $1,420, because concessions were booked as a leasing cost line rather than a rent reduction. Underwriting that takes the T-12 at face value and projects 3 percent rent growth from $1,420 is growing from a number that does not exist in the market today. The honest going-in rent is $1,302, and the gap between that and a 3 percent growth line compounds fast enough to move exit value by 8 to 10 percent on a standard cap rate. The assumption doing the most work in those suburban B decks right now is not the growth rate, it is the base. What I want to know from people active in this segment is whether their credit committees are requiring net effective rent as the underwriting base, or whether the concession structure is still passing through acquisition at asking rent with a note in the footnotes?