Discussion
A 180-unit acquisition underwrites to 94 percent market rents on day one, with a 24-month glide path to get the in-place roll to market. That sounds orderly until you sit with wha…
Discussion
The instinct makes sense. Submarket has softened, land sellers are more realistic, construction pricing has come off peak, so you buy low into a trough and deliver into a recovery…
Discussion
A controller at a mid-market operator said something to me last week that I have been turning over since: most buyers model the current assessed value forward with a modest annual…
Discussion
Has anyone actually gotten counsel to draft language that pins this down, or is vagueness the point?
Discussion
I'm looking at a 312-unit deal in Phoenix right now where the T-3 shows $1,680 average and the in-place leases from that window are rolling off over the next 18 months. The sponso…
Loss
Take a case worth studying: an investor puts $50k into an LP interest in a 312 unit value-add deal in a Sun Belt metro, sponsor's fifth deal, good track record on the earlier ones…
Poll
The thesis behind most large multifamily pitches right now is straightforward. Apartment values reset, supply falls off, rents firm up somewhere around 2027, and whoever bought at…
Happening Now
Take a preferred equity offering on a 300-unit 2019-vintage asset where the real question is whose value the position is protected against. Structure as presented: a fixed-rate ag…
Discussion
Three apartment fund PPMs, all describing themselves as value-add, can turn out to mean three very different things. One buys 2019 vintage lease-ups at a discount and does essenti…
Happening Now
This is the allocation I've been circling since summer and I have to decide before year end because one of the funds closes. The fund: value-add multifamily, Sun Belt and lower mi…
Discussion
Take a three-property, 1,100-unit value-add portfolio an institutional buyer has just taken down, with interior renovation scope going out to bid: LVP, quartz caps over existing b…
Poll
The recovery case rests on absorption overtaking deliveries and staying there long enough for rents to firm. Everyone models the pipeline contraction. Almost nobody models the res…
Discussion
I'm starting from nothing here and I want to understand the cost structure of an acquisitions operation before I understand anything else. Everything I read talks about markets an…
Happening Now
Here is a scenario worth working through, because the clause at the center of it shows up in most closed-end fund documents. An LP is asked for a $250k commitment to a closed-end…
Discussion
A management company built around 40 to 120 unit properties for local owners will typically find the requirements change once a 320-unit institutional buyer enters the picture. A…
Happening Now
Studying for the license and one of the brokers at the office let me sit in on a 180 unit listing. The offering memorandum leads with $172,000 per unit against a "replacement cost…
Loss
A useful case to study involves a co-invest into two multifamily properties, 466 units total, 1998 and 2001 vintage, one metro, closed in spring 2022 at roughly $205,000 a door. T…
Poll
I'm doing scope pricing for a group buying a 288 unit 1996-vintage property in a Sun Belt submarket where deliveries are dropping off hard after 2026. Two scopes on the table and…
Discussion
Trying to read a submarket and the published numbers and the property-level numbers don't agree at all. The market report says asking rents in this submarket are down 1.4% year ov…
Happening Now
Here is a screen worth arguing with. Say an operator has spent six months building a buy list and the ranking finally produces something they do not trust. The screen ranks on for…
Poll
Across several recent value-add memos, the structure of the rent assumption tends to repeat. Year one flat to slightly negative, concessions burning off by month 14 to 18, then 3.…
Poll
I spend most of my time on land, so this is outside my lane. What got my attention is that the pipeline for new apartments is contracting sharply and vacancy looks like it topped…
Discussion
Here is a deck worth walking through as a room, because it lands in front of first time readers all the time and the language in it is doing a lot of work. Say a regional apartmen…
Happening Now
I have a subscription agreement on my desk for an LP position in a single-asset deal and I keep circling the same page. Writing this out partly for myself, and partly because I wa…
Discussion
Every institutional apartment piece I read says the same thing, which is that vacancy has peaked around 8.5% and values sit 20 to 30% under the 2022 high, so this is the moment fo…
Happening Now
312 units, 2016 vintage garden, bought late 2021 at $228k a door. Floating rate bridge, cap bought at the time, cap expires in five months. My LP position is small, call it 4 perc…
Happening Now
Two deals worth comparing at the same equity check size. Deal A: 176 units, 1985 vintage, garden style, inner-ring suburb of a midwest metro. $118k a door. Rents about $310 under…
Discussion
Working through a deal a mentor sent me so I can see how the bigger end underwrites. 300 units, 2016 vintage, secondary Sun Belt market. Ask is $72m, so $240k a door. The sponsor'…
Poll
Operators who come from the build side tend to trust replacement cost more than any other number in the model, which is exactly the bias worth checking hardest. Consider a 312-uni…
Win
First full program I've been responsible for placing, and the thing that worked was refusing to fund it all at the first close. Mandate was $22M into multifamily, patient money, n…
Poll
I've got capital to place and no operating experience, so the whole pitch I keep getting handed is timing. National apartment vacancy around 8.5 percent, described as peaked, fore…
Poll
Most institutional apartment decks in this cycle show the same return bridge. Buy 20 to 30 percent under the 2022 peak. Renovate and push rents. Exit into a firmer market in 2029…
Win
For anyone learning the lending side rather than the owning side, a loan participation is a good first structure to study, and a worked example shows where the risk actually sits.…
Happening Now
This is a scenario worth thinking through carefully before committing capital, since the assumptions carry more weight than they first appear to. Take a 302 unit, 1998 vintage pro…
Happening Now
Consider a twelve year, $2M allocation with two ways in. Option one is an open end core plus multifamily fund: 0.85 percent on NAV, no promote below a threshold rarely triggered,…