Why does a 97-lot park in a 55-plus age-restricted community price like a standard family park when the resident turnover math is completely different
I have been sitting on this one for about six weeks trying to figure out if the age restriction is a cap rate penalty or if buyers just are not modeling it at all. The park I am looking at is in Pinal County, 97 lots, roughly 80 percent occupied, lot rent at $395 which is not far below market for the submarket. The age restriction is baked into the CC&Rs and predates the current owner by at least two recorded deeds. Broker sent comps that were straight family parks, no adjustment, nothing. When I pushed on it he said age restrictions do not affect value. I do not think that is right. A 55-plus community limits who can buy a home inside it, which limits how fast you can fill a vacant lot, which limits how fast you can push rent because your resident pool turns over slower and on a less predictable timeline than a family park. The average tenure in a 55-plus park is longer, yes, but when a lot does go vacant the replacement clock runs differently. I have one private lender who will look at it but she wants a 90-day occupancy stabilization clause before she will fund the full advance, and I think she is reading the risk correctly. The exit also bothers me. If I am three years into a business plan and I want to sell, my buyer pool narrows because whoever acquires it either operates 55-plus specifically or has to learn it. I cannot figure out if the market is just ignoring the distinction or if the longer average tenure actually absorbs enough of the downside that the comp methodology is defensible.