8.2x coverage on the senior and the pref investor still took a haircut at exit
Dayton deal, 72 units, closed 2021. Senior was a small regional bank at 55 percent LTC, debt service coverage sitting at 8.2x on stabilized actuals when the hold ended. Pref was $600k at 10 percent current, 18-month redemption target that slid to 31 months. Sponsor hit the redemption date, paid it out, and the pref investor walked with something like 8.6 percent effective once you account for the slip. Not a loss, nothing dramatic, but the coverage ratio I keep seeing people cite as the comfort metric did nothing for the return degradation. The 8.2x told you the senior was fine. It told you nothing about the 13 months of extra carry the sponsor absorbed before he could refi out of the pref position, and that carry came out of somewhere. I underwrote a similar structure in Akron in March, same vintage of regional bank debt, and I passed because the redemption mechanics assumed an exit cap 40 basis points tighter than anything trading in that zip code. The coverage looked great on paper. The pref investor in that deal is still in it. I am not saying coverage is useless, but I keep watching people treat a high DSCR on the senior as a proxy for pref safety, and those are two different questions.