Discussion
I keep underwriting deals with a preferred equity structure and telling myself it functions like senior debt because I get paid before common, but the more I read the more I think…
Discussion
A $2M raise with an 8 percent preferred return accrues $160,000 a year, and I keep seeing LP updates that report distributions paid without ever showing how much of that figure is…
Discussion
A six month CO delay does not just push the lease-up calendar. It runs the preferred return clock on committed equity for another two quarters, compresses the stabilization window…
Win
Sponsor acquired a 68,000 sf office building in the medical district for $19 a foot in late 2022. That is not a typo. The seller was a regional insurance company that had been try…
Story
I had the deal page open for about three weeks. Mixed-use adaptive reuse in Youngstown, 72 units over ground-floor commercial, preferred equity at 8% with a 1.75x equity multiple…
Discussion
I have 15k sitting between deals and I keep landing on these two as the actual comparison. The office note is 24 months, first lien, a 2021 vintage asset in Overland Park that sur…
Story
A deal worth studying: a 72-unit value-add, $1.8 million pref tranche sitting at a 14 percent preferred return, with a redemption date set at month 36. The pref documents defined…
Happening Now
Got an amendment last week from the fund GP on my hotel LP position. The original docs said preferred return at 8% before promote kicks in, pari passu across LP class. The amendme…
Discussion
I have been looking at this because I am working with a buyer whose structure is a single-member LLC formed in Delaware about four months ago, and the sole member is a Canadian na…
Discussion
Looking at two things right now. A developer I know is raising on a 3 MW colocation shell outside Łódź, passive preferred equity, 14 percent preferred, 36-month projected hold, mi…
Happening Now
Walked a 72-unit last spring in Dayton where the pref investor thought he had the wheel and the senior agreement made the whole thing decorative. Curious how often people read pas…
Happening Now
Looking at a deal in Cincinnati, $4.2M stabilized retail strip, senior lender has a full appraisal in at $4.05M, sponsor is asking me to come in at $380K mezz between the senior a…
Happening Now
That framing does real damage. The enforcement right that makes a pref position feel like a loan analog is a removal right, and exercising it does not land you in fee simple owner…
Win
Bought into the stack at $1.1M about 22 months ago, 10 percent pref, second position behind a regional bank at about 62 percent LTV on the as-converted value. The sponsor was a mi…
Discussion
I put $7,500 into a preferred equity position on a mixed-use rehab in Corpus Christi, 18-month projected hold, 8.5% preferred return. Deal is now 26 months in. The sponsor sent a…
Story
The developer ran out of runway at month nineteen. Construction was 70% complete, the utility interconnection was still eight months out, and the GP had burned through the interes…
Loss
A manufactured housing community deal worth studying: a 180-pad community underwritten at 92 percent occupancy, with a value-add plan built around infilling 22 vacant pads over 18…
Discussion
I keep running this comparison on the Phoenix multifamily deal I'm circling and the numbers keep not quite matching up. The operator is projecting a cash-out refi at month 36 afte…
Loss
I put in $5,000 last October, which is not life-changing money but it is my first intentional real estate investment as opposed to the two things I inherited. The deal is a wareho…
Happening Now
A deal I have been turning over lately involves a preferred equity position that converts to common interest if the sponsor misses two consecutive preferred distributions. The str…
Win
The structure was 10 percent current pay, no accrual, hard redemption at month 24, and a removal right that actually had teeth because the senior was a regional bank willing to co…
Win
The numbers in this case are worth walking through. A $2,000,000 preferred equity piece at 14 percent annualized, with a pref return accruing daily, was projected to be redeemed a…
Discussion
Say a capital provider puts in $500k on a 10 percent preferred return and a 70/30 promote above a 1.8x equity multiple. The operator refi's at month 18, pulls out $480k, and retur…
Discussion
Asking because I have a note right now where the sponsor skipped Q3 and Q4 distributions and the PPM language says "cumulative preferred return" but does not specify whether the a…
Happening Now
I run a small debt fund so I spend a lot of time thinking about where I sit in the capital stack, and preferred shares on public REITs have started showing up in conversations I'm…
Discussion
I'm looking at getting back into another Texas multifamily deal, this time as preferred equity rather than LP. The sponsor is offering 8 percent preferred with a 2x equity multipl…
Discussion
I have been looking at waterfall structures where the sponsor takes an asset management fee, a construction management fee, and sometimes a development fee, all of which sit senio…
Discussion
The stack diagram puts pref between the senior debt and the common equity, and that feels intuitive, like a queue. Senior gets paid first, then pref, then common. But the queue on…
Discussion
Take a $200k allocation and two places it could sit. The first is a preferred equity position in a 20 MW build to suit in Gainesville, Virginia. Senior debt is $180M, total capita…
Discussion
Here is a case worth studying for anyone in a pref position on a value-add deal with bridge debt. Picture a pref investor 14 months into a 36-month hold on a 220-unit garden compl…
Win
A structure worth examining. A 2.1 million preferred equity position on a 48 unit deal, 9.5 percent current pay, 18 month term with two six month extensions, written as first loss…
Discussion
Looked at from the capital side, the boarding houses that attract preferred equity are the 12 to 18 room properties where the operator understands licensing and management but can…
Discussion
This produces two different answers depending on which capital event you assume, and it is worth walking through with real numbers. Take a 48,000 sf spec industrial shell outside…
Loss
We put $2.4m of pref into a 78-unit value-add through a small group, 11% total return, 4% current pay and the rest accruing, three year redemption. The docs looked fine to me at t…
Discussion
A sponsor holding fully entitled land asked me to come in with $1.5m of preferred equity at 13 percent, all accruing, since the land produces nothing until it's sold or a construc…
Poll
I'm working out what my first deal really costs and pref equity keeps coming up as the thing that fills the gap between what a bank will lend and what a sponsor has. Every explana…
Poll
In a recap where a sponsor offers a choice of where preferred equity sits, the decision usually comes down to two structures worth weighing against each other directly. Option one…
Poll
Comparing four preferred equity structures for a fund allocation surfaces a real tension: the protections trade against each other, and nobody gets all of them at a price that cle…
Poll
Consider a 180-unit garden deal where the senior is sized to a 1.20x coverage on its own and the sponsor needs another 4.5 million to close the refi gap, with the old mortgage aro…
Poll
I've been reading pref equity summaries for a couple of months and one line keeps stopping me. The pref investor doesn't get a mortgage on the property. You get a membership inter…
Discussion
A sponsor I follow is raising a preferred equity tranche on a 90-unit deal and the minimum is $250,000. Then I read a piece that said retail investors get into pref for $50,000 or…
Happening Now
Two live pref term sheets on comparable assets are worth laying side by side to see how the math actually behaves. Say both are $1.5M checks into recapitalizations of suburban mul…
Happening Now
Take a pref position on a 140 unit 1980s value-add where the position doesn't cover itself out of operations for the first two years, and the question becomes what that gap is wor…
Discussion
An amended LLC agreement on a construction deal can define a Preferred Return Default as failing to pay the current portion for two consecutive months or failing to redeem by the…
Poll
Reading pref documents rather than doing them turns up the same negotiation in nearly every one. The sponsor will concede either economic certainty or timing certainty, rarely bot…
Happening Now
Sponsor I've co-invested with twice is recapitalizing a 190 unit garden complex and asked if I'd take the pref piece. My money is usually in land and long holds, so this is new te…
Discussion
A preferred equity tranche at 12 percent is worth pulling apart carefully, especially for anyone coming from the lending side where subordinate capital usually means mezz: a loan,…
Loss
$900k into a pref position on a suburban office-to-flex conversion, 12% accruing, no current pay for the first eighteen months, 1.35x minimum multiple at redemption. I read the wh…
Discussion
The offering document for a typical pref tranche says accredited investors only. A claim that circulates in other forums is that preferred equity is debt like, so it is not really…
Loss
Writing this from the sponsor side. Mid-size industrial infill, five buildings, $14.2m purchase. Senior loan was $9.1m fixed for five years with defeasance and a lockout through y…
Poll
Everything I read puts pref equity returns in roughly the 10 to 15 percent band. That's a wide band for a single asset class and I don't yet have a feel for what moves you across…