The clause that lets the pref investor fire the sponsor

Question

Reading an amended LLC agreement for a preferred equity piece on a construction deal and one section stopped me. On a "Preferred Return Default", defined as failing to pay the current portion for two consecutive months or failing to redeem by the outside date, the pref member automatically becomes the managing member and the sponsor's interest converts to non-voting. The rate also bumps by 5 percent a year while the default continues.

Is that boilerplate in this market? And assuming it's enforceable, what does a pref investor do the morning after they take over a half-finished building?

Rena Guide · Accepted Answer

That's the standard remedy package for preferred equity, and it exists because of the structure. There's no lien, so the investor can't foreclose on the building. The only lever available sits inside the LLC agreement, which is why these documents hand the pref member control of the entity when payments stop. Market shorthand calls a position with a mandatory redemption date and self-help removal rights a hard pref, and one where the return only accrues as cash allows, with weaker remedies, a soft pref.

Whether the automatic removal actually operates the way the page describes depends on the specific language and on the LLC statute of the state of formation, and that's a question for a lawyer licensed there. Courts have looked at these provisions and the outcomes are not uniform.

Most agreements also give the sponsor a cure window, often 10 to 30 days, and sometimes limit how many times it can cure before the conversion becomes permanent.

The morning after is the hard part. Whoever takes over inherits the general contractor, the draw schedule, the construction lender's conditions, and possibly a guarantor who has stopped answering. Senior lenders know this, which is why they typically insist on approving any replacement manager in advance. In practice the 5 percent bump often does more work than the removal right, because it prices the delay while the parties renegotiate. Ask the sponsor and yourself who would actually run the job if the clause fired.

paulgrant17 · Answer

If the pref member becomes the manager, do the leases and the property management contract move at all? Or does the LLC still own everything and only the person signing changes?

aliyah_b · Answer

Two consecutive months as the trigger is what I'd push back on hardest as sponsor. One insurance renewal landing in a bad collections month and you've handed over the company on a technicality.

hannah_west29 · Answer

The bump is the number I'd model before the removal right. $3m pref going from 12 to 17 and accruing monthly puts roughly $550k on the meter in a year, and it all comes out of the common at exit. A sponsor can sign away the entire promote over two soft quarters and not notice until the waterfall runs.

raj_mehta14 · Answer

So nobody forecloses on anything, the pref holder just becomes the boss of the LLC. Does something get filed with the state when that happens or is it purely internal paper?

dpatel_re · Answer

I've seen worse triggers than two months, including any breach of a coverage covenant regardless of whether cash was short. I'd want 10 business days to cure plus an express right to fund the shortfall out of a reserve before conversion, and I'd want the outside redemption date pushed past the construction loan's maturity. Otherwise the trigger can fire for reasons the sponsor genuinely can't fix.

chriswalton8 · Answer

Does the sponsor ever get voting rights back? If the pref eventually gets paid in full, is the conversion reversed or is it gone for good once tripped?

wendy_park48 · Answer

@vellum depends on the state. Some require the manager named in the annual report or a statement of authority to be updated, others keep management entirely inside the operating agreement with nothing public. The document I'd read next is the senior loan's definition of permitted transfer, because the same event that gives @warrant his remedy can be a mortgage default, and the recognition agreement is where the lender pre-blesses a replacement manager. Without that, the clause is a threat rather than a plan.

marcus_hale41 · Answer

First thing I ask for in a pref data room is the completion guaranty. If the guarantor and the party the removal right points at aren't the same balance sheet, the removal right doesn't get you paid.

stephen_ok9 · Answer

Why would a pref investor ever actually pull the trigger instead of renegotiating? Taking over a construction job you didn't underwrite sounds worse than a rate bump and a new schedule.

sonia_alvarez · Answer

@meridian that's how it reads to me too. The clause is what gets the sponsor to the table, and the accrual keeps the clock running while everyone talks.

The clause that lets the pref investor fire the sponsor

11 replies