Happening Now
He said every serious LP he met already knew the return math. What they were doing during the call was deciding whether he would pick up the phone at 11pm on a bad Thursday. That…
Discussion
Eighteen months into a 72-unit value-add in Dayton, the deal went sideways on reno cost overruns and the GP called a capital event I did not fully understand until after I signed…
Discussion
A $2M raise with an 8 percent preferred return accrues $160,000 a year, and I keep seeing LP updates that report distributions paid without ever showing how much of that figure is…
Discussion
Mine goes into basis, specifically it lowers the cap rate I'll accept at exit because a buyer eight years from now is buying two years of abatement, not ten. I've seen decks where…
Win
That framing is the part worth pulling apart. When a rate cap expires and the replacement costs more than the original, the difference lands directly on cash flow, and if the deal…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a 240-unit workforce housing acquisition underwritten at $1,195 average in-place rent, with a value-add thesis projecting $1,380 at stabilization. The spons…
Win
Met this seller through probate, Maricopa County, late 2023. His brother left him a small apartment building and he had been self-managing it for about four years. Asked him what…
Loss
I found that buried in the sources and uses on page 31. Not the cover, not the summary, page 31. The deal was marketed as a stabilized value-add with a seven-year hold, and the sp…
Story
Legal ran $24,000, the PPM alone was $14,500 of that. The rest is dead in earnest money, travel to Greensboro four times in six months, two rounds of environmental reports because…
Discussion
A sponsor walks into a raise saying cap rates have compressed in their target market, so the entry price reflects that reality and the exit assumption is conservative. That framin…
Story
A 200-unit deal closes with a five-year hold in the deck, 7 percent pref, 70/30 split above an 8 percent IRR hurdle. Year four, the sponsor cannot hit the exit cap needed to prote…
Discussion
A friend who runs a small family office told me this week that she only found out because she recognized a different name on the quarterly signature block. No letter, no amendment…
Happening Now
Somebody sent me a deal last week, 228 units outside of Charlotte, and buried in the operating agreement was language that said the sponsor could restructure the distribution wate…
Story
A deal worth studying: a 72-unit value-add, $1.8 million pref tranche sitting at a 14 percent preferred return, with a redemption date set at month 36. The pref documents defined…
Happening Now
A deal worth sitting with: a 48-unit value-add, GP raises LP equity at the typical terms, 8 percent preferred return, 70/30 split above that. Eighteen months in, the bridge lender…
Happening Now
Got a deck on a 96 unit in Mesquite, Texas. T12 NOI looks reasonable until you pull the rent roll history and see occupancy was sitting at 54 percent through most of Q1 and Q2 las…
Story
I almost passed on the Shreveport mixed use because of the ground floor retail. Everybody I talked to said the same thing, commercial vacancy eats your NOI, retail tenants take fo…
Happening Now
Fourteen months into a 72-unit deal in Stone Mountain. NOI came in about 11% below pro forma because two of the commercial bays on the ground floor sat dark longer than I underwro…
Happening Now
This comes up enough that it is worth sitting with. The raise that follows a miss is often larger than the one that preceded it, and the explanation is not that investors are irra…
Loss
Six quarters of on-time distributions sounds like a healthy deal until you ask where the cash came from. A reserve account funded at close, say $180,000 on a $1.2 million raise, c…
Discussion
A 24-month construction schedule that runs to 30 months is common enough that nobody panics. What they miss is that six months of accrued preferred return on, say, $4 million in L…
Loss
The reserves line sat at $180,000 across Q2, Q3, Q4 and Q1 of the following year, through a roof replacement and two HVAC units. The capital did not come from reserves. It came fr…
Loss
The deal was a 64-unit value-add in a secondary market, five-year hold, 14 percent target IRR. Investors got back 80 cents on the dollar. The letter cited rising rates, constructi…
Discussion
Came up in a deal I am watching from the debt side. Original sponsor brought in a co-GP about eight months into a 36-month hold on a 48-unit value-add in suburban Columbus. Fine,…
Discussion
Most LPs read that clause as a formality. Fourteen days to wire fresh money is not a formality if you are three years into a deal and the lender just issued a covenant waiver with…
Discussion
Had an LP in the Tampa fund put in a redemption request four months ago, not a hostile one, just a liquidity need. The way the sponsor handled the acknowledgment, the timeline, th…
Discussion
I've been reading PPMs for the last six weeks trying to understand what sponsors actually have to disclose, and this specific situation keeps coming up without a clear answer. Dea…
Happening Now
It does not reset unless the operating agreement says it does, and almost none of them say that. The question matters because a capital call that gets treated as a new contributio…
Discussion
The question I keep landing on is whether the two tools actually fit together or whether the OZ structure ends up fighting the lender. The equity side wants a ten year hold to cap…
Happening Now
A 200-unit multifamily acquisition, purchase price $28 million, senior loan at 65 percent LTV covers $18.2 million, equity comes in at $5 million, and the $4.8 million gap gets fi…
Happening Now
A 70/30 split above an 8 percent pref sounds standard, and for many deals it is. The question worth sitting with is what the 30 percent is actually taken against. Some waterfall s…
Discussion
I run leasing for other people's buildings so I spend a lot of time thinking about what owners want to know and when they want to know it. I have been watching how sponsors in thi…
Loss
A manufactured housing community deal worth studying: a 180-pad community underwritten at 92 percent occupancy, with a value-add plan built around infilling 22 vacant pads over 18…
Discussion
Closing fee is one month's rent, renewal is $350, and there's a $150 admin fee on every new lease on top of all of it. Ran the actual dollar number against gross collected for 202…
Discussion
I have been looking at a deal where the pref accrues monthly, distributions come quarterly, and the projected exit is in month 38. The sponsor is showing a 17.4 percent IRR on a 1…
Discussion
I'm looking at a 38-unit in Wrocław and the numbers only work if I keep management in house. Wondering how much friction that creates with outside LPs when the fee goes to the sam…
Discussion
Most sponsors I see spend two weeks on the initial deck and twenty minutes on the bad-news update, which is backwards. The update is the audition. Take a deal where month four bri…
Win
A sponsor I was reviewing materials for this week quoted a new 5,000 sf lease at $32 per sf full service, which looked fine against the submarket comp sheet. What the deck did not…
Happening Now
Trying to learn the structure on a deal I passed on last month, a 62-unit in Rockford that stalled at about 40 percent of its $3.2M equity target before the sponsor pulled it. The…
Discussion
A sponsor I follow closely held 47 LPs through a refinancing that failed to close on schedule, and the original five-year hold stretched toward seven with no clear exit in sight.…
Win
I have seen two offering memos this month where the AM fee stays at 1.25 percent of gross revenue through the whole hold. One deal is a value-add in Stark County, projected 48-mon…
Loss
I was a co-GP on a 24-unit in Phoenix, closed September 2022, $1.8M raise. The operating partner handled LP communications and I assumed that meant something. First update went ou…
Win
The numbers in this case are worth walking through. A $2,000,000 preferred equity piece at 14 percent annualized, with a pref return accruing daily, was projected to be redeemed a…
Discussion
Most capital decks I read still anchor the insurance line to trailing actuals from the seller, sometimes two years old, sometimes older. That made sense when premiums were predict…
Happening Now
A 1.75x EM over five years works out to roughly 11.8 percent annualized if you compound it straight. Getting from there to 15 percent IRR requires the model to front-load cash flo…
Story
A deal with a 7 percent pref and a 70/30 split sounds straightforward, but the calculation changes materially depending on whether the pref accrues on committed capital from day o…
Happening Now
Talking to a sponsor in Phoenix about a 72-unit value-add, $4.1M raise, and the way the co-GP structure is drawn up I would carry 80% of the personal guaranty while they take 50%…
Discussion
A sponsor I was looking at recently had a conversion under contract, city overlay in place, feasibility done, and a pro forma that closed cleanly. Then the building department iss…
Discussion
Most PPMs I read say the LP preferred return accrues from the date capital is funded. That sounds clean until you look at a deal where equity sits in escrow for six weeks before t…
Discussion
The K-1 showed the loss. The update talked about occupancy and debt service coverage. Not one LP would have known to connect the two, which means not one LP could have asked wheth…
Discussion
I have been looking at waterfall structures where the sponsor takes an asset management fee, a construction management fee, and sometimes a development fee, all of which sit senio…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a 72-unit value-add acquisition, $4.2M equity raise, 8 percent cumulative pref, 75/25 split above that, projected 18 percent IRR on a five-year hold. The nu…
Story
Everyone in this room treats the first conversation as the audition, and it often is. The part that takes longer to accept is that a no on a specific deal is almost never a no on…
Discussion
Take a 22 unit that costs about 4,200 a month to operate hands on, where an asset management fee set at 1.5 percent of gross comes to roughly 1,890. The 2,300 difference is real l…
Loss
$4.1M sale on a $3.8M basis, so the math looked fine going in. Property sat longer than projected, distributions got suspended in year 3, and the pref kept compounding. By the tim…
Discussion
I had modeled 1.5% going in, which would have been $43,500, but my attorney flagged a clause we negotiated at LOI that I had completely forgotten about, tied to the final purchase…
Discussion
Here is a case worth studying for anyone in a pref position on a value-add deal with bridge debt. Picture a pref investor 14 months into a 36-month hold on a 220-unit garden compl…
Discussion
This produces two different answers depending on which capital event you assume, and it is worth walking through with real numbers. Take a 48,000 sf spec industrial shell outside…
Happening Now
This is one that genuinely lacks a clean answer. Say a sponsor closes a 32-unit deal in Q1, the LLC is formed and capital is deployed. Then the next deal does not come together un…
Poll
From the debt side, the first question worth asking about any sponsor's deck is what happens if a deal goes badly, not what happens if it goes well, and track record is where that…