Should I sell the Decatur duplex or convert it and hold through the rate environment
Bought it in 2021 for $298k, put about $22k into it before the first guest checked in. Both units ran as STR through most of 2022 and into 2023. Combined gross last year was $61,400, which sounds fine until you count the platform fees, the cleaning crew I finally stopped doing myself in March, the HVAC on the bottom unit in August ($3,100), and the fact that I am still carrying a 6.875% rate on a refi I did last spring when I thought I had a reason to pull cash out. Net after all of that came to just under $19k for the year. On a $298k purchase that is not a number I am proud of.
The Decatur STR market got noticeably softer in Q3 last year. I track my own comp set manually every few months and the same properties that were booking at $145 a night in summer 2022 are sitting at $112 and still showing gaps mid-week. My occupancy on the top unit dropped from 68% in 2022 to 54% last year. The bottom unit did better mostly because I priced it lower and stopped caring about ADR, which is its own kind of admission.
What I keep turning over is whether converting both units to long-term at market rent, somewhere around $1,150 to $1,200 each based on what I see renting in the 30030 and 30032 zip codes right now, actually closes the gap or just trades one problem for a different one. At $2,350 combined gross monthly that is $28,200 a year before vacancy and maintenance, which is not far off from $19k net STR once I stop pretending STR doesn't have its own vacancy. The difference is the long-term version does not require me to touch it every week.
The sell case is that the market might keep softening, I have six other properties and the mental load on this one is disproportionate, and if I sold today at something close to the $370k I think it would appraise at I could clear the note and have roughly $55k to redeploy somewhere that isn't already taking my attention. The hold and convert case is that I locked in the asset, rents in Decatur are not going down, and selling at $370k means I'm paying tax on the gain at a point in my income where that is not a small number.
I have not decided. I am running the actual conversion numbers this month with real rent comps instead of estimates.