Lender-preferred title on a $300,000 purchase came in $2,200 higher, and RESPA still let the lender push it.
Section 9 of RESPA prohibits a seller from requiring the buyer to use a specific title company as a condition of sale, but it says nothing about lender preference. A lender can require title insurance and can require an approved underwriter list without triggering a Section 9 violation, so the $2,200 premium difference sits entirely with the buyer unless they push back. The mechanism that matters is whether the lender's list is genuinely open or functionally a single referral dressed as a list. If the preferred company and the lender share a business arrangement, AFBA disclosure is required and the buyer has standing to ask for it in writing before closing. Most buyers never ask. On a $300,000 loan the owner's policy at a filed rate runs roughly $1,000 to $1,400 depending on state. A $2,200 spread against that is not a rounding error, it is the whole policy again. The assumption doing the most work in these situations is that the lender's preferred company is cheaper because of volume. Sometimes that is true on the lender's policy, where the simultaneous issue discount compresses the gap. Sometimes the preferred company prices the owner's policy higher precisely because buyers assume the lender has already vetted the value. The number to compare is not the total closing estimate, it is the two title lines on the CD side by side, same loan amount, same coverage. What was the breakdown between lender's policy and owner's policy on the higher quote?