Second truck at 22 jobs a month, or am I paying $2,400 for idle time

Your breakeven arithmetic is right and it's also measuring the wrong constraint. You aren't short on trucks at 22 jobs a month, you're short on productive hours inside a fixed truck day, and a second truck only fixes that if the incremental jobs cluster geographically. Two jobs eleven miles apart is a real second job. Two jobs forty minutes apart with a transfer station on the wrong end is one job plus a paid drive.

The number carrying your whole case is the $330 gross on incremental work, and it assumes turned-down jobs look like accepted jobs. They usually don't. What you decline first is the awkward stuff, the second-floor walkup, the hoarder unit, the one three counties out. Price those at your current average and the margin comes in under $330 while the hours come in over five.

Disposal at $180 average also deserves a look before you commit to fixed monthly iron. If your servicer's allowable caps the volume you can bill without pre-approval, heavy jobs get eaten by your own margin, and adding capacity multiplies that exposure rather than diluting it.

Subbing overflow keeps the exposure variable and costs you the margin on those six jobs. That's the trade. What it also costs is control of the photo record and the completion timeline, and if the sub's uploads get rejected the chargeback lands on your vendor number, not theirs. Read your vendor agreement on that before you sub anything.

The other thing to check is what your servicer volume actually rests on. REO assignments arrive as a portfolio, and portfolios move between servicers and get re-bid. Confirm in writing whether you have any volume commitment or a termination for convenience clause, because a 60-month truck note against 30-day work is the structure that hurts people in this trade.

Your overflow from me isn't truck work. Turnover cleans on my units need a van, a vacuum, and a crew that shows inside a 48 hour window between tenants, and I'll pay reliably for that all year. If you buy a box truck to serve my scheduling problem you've bought the wrong vehicle. Ask which of those six declined jobs actually need cubic yards hauled.

What does subbing actually cost in practice, is it a flat percentage off your invoice or do they price the job themselves and you mark it up?

A 16-foot box truck holds resale value better than most equipment you could buy at $2,400 a month, so the downside isn't total. But you're financing a monthly payment against work that arrives in bursts, and that mismatch is the actual risk, not the residual value.

@sextant if those declined jobs are further out, check the hauler registration in the counties they're in before you count the revenue. I found out my registration doesn't travel across a county line here and the transfer station on that side wouldn't open a commercial account without it. Weeks, not days.

Skip the second truck for heavy loads and drop a 20-yard roll-off at the property. $450 to $600 delivered and hauled in my area depending on tonnage, and your two guys load it in place instead of driving to the scale twice. Works badly on tight urban lots and HOA streets where you can't get a permit.

The re-bid point deserves more weight than it's getting. If one servicer is most of your 22 jobs, what does the month after they lose the portfolio look like with two truck payments? I'd want the answer written down before signing anything.

Ran your numbers. At $330 a job you need 7.3 jobs to cover the $2,400, then the second crew's idle hours on top, so realistically 10 or 11 before it's better than today. That's a 50% volume increase on the strength of a servicer saying volume is going up.

Pull the vendor agreement and find the photo and documentation spec, then find the chargeback language. The ones I've read let the servicer reduce or reverse a completed invoice for documentation deficiencies with no time limit stated, and they define the vendor as responsible for subcontractor work. So @beacon's question about markup matters less than who eats a rejected upload sixty days later.

I don't believe the $780 average is stable enough to plan capacity off. Split the 22 jobs into buckets and I'd guess four or five big ones are carrying the mean while a dozen small lock-and-loads sit at $300. If that's the shape, how busy the second truck stays depends entirely on whether the big jobs keep arriving, and you can't schedule those.

Watch for tires and paint on the outdoor jobs. Lot cleanouts near me get quoted like debris and then the scale house charges per tire separately, and anything the station calls hazardous doesn't go in your truck at all. That's a line item and a second trip.

From the hiring end, I'd pay a premium for the crew that turns up when they said with a dolly and a shop vac already on the truck. Two of the outfits I've used sent one guy and a pickup for a job quoted as a two-man haul. If a second truck is what makes you dependable across two jobs a day, that's worth more to me than a lower price.

Why does the disposal cost swing so much, is it purely the weight or does the station charge differently for the type of material?

@juniper it's mostly weight, but mattresses, appliances and tires usually carry their own per-item fee on top, which is why @sextant's $180 average hides a lot.

I've been listing service outfits in my market and the ones that seem steadiest rent a truck by the day at $90 to $130 plus mileage when they get a second job, and never own the second one. Doesn't scale, but nothing sits idle either.