Does a QOF fund of funds structure actually give you more diversification or just more fee drag
I have been looking at a vehicle that sits between LP and the underlying QOFs, so it invests in four or five funds rather than directly into projects. The pitch is diversification across markets and asset types without the work of evaluating each fund manager separately. The fee structure though is what I keep getting stuck on. There is a management fee at the FOF level and then each underlying QOF charges its own, so by the time you model out a 10-year hold with two layers taking their cut, the net appreciation you actually see starts to look thinner than the marketing deck implies.
What I cannot figure out is whether the tax benefit still justifies the double fee load. If I dropped the same gain into a single well-run QOF at a 1.5% annual fee, I would pay less in total drag even if the underlying deal concentration is higher. The FOF is charging 75 basis points on top of that, which compounds over a decade into something that actually shows up.
There is also the question of timing control. If the FOF manager is deploying into funds that are still accumulating capital, some of those underlying QOFs might be 12 or 18 months behind on the 90-day clock, which starts pushing against the 90 percent asset test before the projects are even shovel-ready. The FOF layer does not solve that, it just adds distance from the information.
I have not seen a clean analysis of what the FOF structure returns net of both fee layers relative to a single fund over a 10-year hold. If anyone has run that math I would be curious what the crossover point is.