The sponsor's rent survey is dated fourteen months ago and the market has moved
A deal worth studying: a 240-unit workforce housing acquisition underwritten at $1,195 average in-place rent, with a value-add thesis projecting $1,380 at stabilization. The sponsor's comps are from a broker relationship that goes back eight years. The broker knows the asset, knows the sponsor, and ran the survey once, at LOI. Fourteen months have passed. New product delivered six blocks away. The gap between what the deck says rents will be and what a fresh canvassing of comparable units actually shows is now the number doing the most work in the return projection, and no one in the LP stack has asked for an updated survey before funding.
The familiar broker is not running a current survey because no one is requiring one. That is the structural problem. A sponsor who controls the broker relationship also controls the timing of the rent information, and "we used a reputable local broker" is not the same as "this data is current." Fourteen months in a market that absorbed new supply is long enough for effective rents to move fifty to eighty dollars in either direction, and at 240 units, eighty dollars is $230,000 in annual gross potential income. That is not a rounding error in a stabilized NOI model, it is the difference between hitting the projected cap rate and missing it by a turn.
The ask I would make before wiring: an independent rent survey ordered by the LP group, not the sponsor, within thirty days of closing. Some sponsors will push back. The ones who push back hardest are the ones where the existing survey is doing the most work.
What does the offering memo say about how rent projections were sourced, and does it name the broker or just call it a third-party market study?