Happening Now
He said every serious LP he met already knew the return math. What they were doing during the call was deciding whether he would pick up the phone at 11pm on a bad Thursday. That…
Win
A site I have been watching in Garfield Heights, a 0.6 acre pad with a former auto parts store on it, got a development pitch attached to it on LoopNet last month. Mixed use, grou…
Discussion
I have been looking at a vehicle that sits between LP and the underlying QOFs, so it invests in four or five funds rather than directly into projects. The pitch is diversification…
Story
A deal worth studying: a sponsor raises 400k through a crowdfunding platform as a second lien at 11 percent on a light industrial conversion. The senior note is 1.8 million. The p…
Loss
Closed in 2021 at $74/sf, full building, two tenants, looked fine on paper. By mid-2023 one tenant was gone and the other renegotiated down to half the space at a rate that made t…
Discussion
I've been sitting with about $190k in capital gains from the fourplex sale and I've been reading offering docs for three months now. The underwriting in most of them is fine, I gu…
Happening Now
A QOF that closed in early 2021 is already inside the window where the 2026 inclusion date starts to press on the deferral math in a concrete way. The deferred gain comes into inc…
Happening Now
A deal worth studying: 280 units, suburban Atlanta, B-minus vintage, asking effective rents flat to prior year. The in-place leases show $1,420 average asking rent. Net effective…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a 240-unit workforce housing acquisition underwritten at $1,195 average in-place rent, with a value-add thesis projecting $1,380 at stabilization. The spons…
Story
Same team, same market, same stated strategy, but now there is a fee layer between me and the asset, and the underlying deals are not disclosed until after I commit. I want to kno…
Discussion
Trying to get my head around this. I understand the appreciation is federally tax-free after a ten-year hold, but I keep getting stuck on how the waterfall eats into that before I…
Loss
The fund presented deed conversions as an edge case, maybe 4 or 5 percent of the book. Twenty-three percent is not an edge case. I put in 200k out of Columbus in late 2021, and ri…
Discussion
A fund closes on a rolling basis, the manager wants your commitment confirmed in five days, and your custodian needs a direction of investment letter reviewed, countersigned, and…
Discussion
My attorney said something to me Tuesday that I cannot stop turning over. He said stabilization is a story you tell while you wait to see if you are right. That was about the Arca…
Happening Now
Say a fund holds a mixed-use OZ development with a floating rate construction loan capped through 2028 and a projected stabilization in mid-2029. The cap expires before the asset…
Happening Now
Got into a Florida-based lien fund in early 2023, $25k minimum, which was about the floor of what they'd take. It's redeeming now, 22 months in, at a 9.1% annualized return net to…
Happening Now
We are in month 18 of a 24-month hold on a 12-unit in Stockton. Original underwriting assumed a 5.8 exit cap. Operator sent a "market update" last week reforecasting at 6.2 and th…
Win
I am in a pooled fund with a 2021 close date and the GP has mentioned extending past year ten twice now in updates, nothing binding, just floated. My gain was $94k, deferred into…
Happening Now
The situation that keeps coming up: a sponsor I have tracked for two years opens a fifth raise before deals two and three have hit their projected stabilization dates. The underly…
Discussion
Went in on a bridge fund about three years ago, first time putting my own money somewhere I wasn't swinging a hammer. Thought I'd read the deck well enough. Missed the origination…
Happening Now
I am sitting with a term sheet where the promote calculation reads "70/30 of net proceeds after return of capital and pref." The word "net" is carrying a lot of weight there, and…
Discussion
I run a crew, so I learned a long time ago that the price buried in the back of a contract is the real price. Deck comes in, projections look solid, the manager walks me through t…
Story
Sitting on this right now. A sponsor I'm in with on a 72-unit in Chandler, AZ originally projected a 36-month hold, we're at month 41 and the refi that was supposed to return 60%…
Discussion
I have been sitting on the sideline long enough that I have watched two full cycles complete from other people's deals, not my own, and what I keep noticing is that the closing do…
Story
A deal worth studying: a 72-unit value-add, $1.8 million pref tranche sitting at a 14 percent preferred return, with a redemption date set at month 36. The pref documents defined…
Happening Now
A deal worth sitting with: a 48-unit value-add, GP raises LP equity at the typical terms, 8 percent preferred return, 70/30 split above that. Eighteen months in, the bridge lender…
Happening Now
Ran into this on a deal I'm looking at right now. The sponsor has three exits listed, all 2019 to 2022, and the deck shows IRRs and multiples for each. I asked for the closing sta…
Win
The structure was a single-asset QOF, a mixed-use development in a census tract that stayed designated through the hold period, acquired in 2019 with a gain reinvested before the…
Discussion
A GP bringing you a deal has already decided the waterfall. The question is whether you are reading the document that locks it in or taking their verbal summary of it. Those two t…
Happening Now
That matters because the interest coverage ratio was technically clean the whole time. The senior was being paid. The platform reported no defaults. What was invisible to anyone r…
Happening Now
A fund that calls capital in January but doesn't close on the underlying QOZB interest until July is sitting on cash for half the measurement period, and the semi-annual test date…
Happening Now
Got an amendment last week from the fund GP on my hotel LP position. The original docs said preferred return at 8% before promote kicks in, pari passu across LP class. The amendme…
Discussion
A sponsor I have been studying recently structured a 48-month projected hold with a standard two-year extension option, and the base-case IRR in the deck assumed month 48 as the e…
Story
A deal worth examining: a non-traded REIT running a $12M value-add industrial portfolio, 68% LTV on the property-level debt, distribution steady at 6.1% annualized through years o…
Discussion
A 24-month construction schedule that runs to 30 months is common enough that nobody panics. What they miss is that six months of accrued preferred return on, say, $4 million in L…
Discussion
A sponsor who says they have "500k in this deal" could mean cash from their own account, a deferred acquisition fee they converted to equity at close, or a loan from a related ent…
Story
Not a course, not a mastermind, just a guy who framed every conversation as "here's what I'd teach you to do" while collecting GP fees from people who thought they were getting me…
Loss
The reserves line sat at $180,000 across Q2, Q3, Q4 and Q1 of the following year, through a roof replacement and two HVAC units. The capital did not come from reserves. It came fr…
Story
Take a 12-unit bought at 1.1 million, with the sponsor collecting a 1 percent asset management fee on gross asset value annually. That is 11,000 a year drawn from LP capital regar…
Discussion
I spent about three weeks on a deck from a fund out of Scottsdale before I noticed the management fee was calculated on committed capital, not deployed capital. On a 5 million rai…
Happening Now
Walked a 72-unit last spring in Dayton where the pref investor thought he had the wheel and the senior agreement made the whole thing decorative. Curious how often people read pas…
Story
Closed my first LP check into a Texas multifamily deal about eight months ago and I'm looking at a second deal now with a different operator. Same basic structure on paper, 8% pre…
Happening Now
When a deal is structured with two general partners sharing promotes, the guaranty on the agency loan almost always lands on one name. The other co-GP sits in the waterfall but no…
Discussion
That label has started to mean something specific to me: the sponsor is buying time before a hard conversation, and the platform is passing the delay along without owning it. What…
Discussion
Most LPs read that clause as a formality. Fourteen days to wire fresh money is not a formality if you are three years into a deal and the lender just issued a covenant waiver with…
Story
A deal worth studying: a syndicator acquires a 48-unit value-add at 6.2 million on a two-year bridge loan at SOFR plus 3.5, with a rate cap purchased at 2 percent SOFR for 18 mont…
Story
A private note paying 9 percent inside a Roth looks clean until you price the idle periods. A 40k note that takes six weeks to close, runs ten months, then sits four weeks before…
Loss
Read the deck three times, asked about the draw schedule on a call, got a confident answer and took it. The actual draw schedule buried in the exhibit was tied to permits that had…
Happening Now
That framing does real damage. The enforcement right that makes a pref position feel like a loan analog is a removal right, and exercising it does not land you in fee simple owner…
Story
I have been reading institutional decks for about eight months now, trying to understand what I am eventually getting into on the capital side even if my first deal is a Cleveland…
Discussion
I've been reading PPMs for the last six weeks trying to understand what sponsors actually have to disclose, and this specific situation keeps coming up without a clear answer. Dea…
Happening Now
Running a small fund myself so I spend a lot of time staring at waterfall structures, and the one I keep coming back to is GP catch-up language that references a hurdle rate but o…
Happening Now
It does not reset unless the operating agreement says it does, and almost none of them say that. The question matters because a capital call that gets treated as a new contributio…
Win
Bought into the stack at $1.1M about 22 months ago, 10 percent pref, second position behind a regional bank at about 62 percent LTV on the as-converted value. The sponsor was a mi…
Happening Now
I inherited a duplex in February and bought into a Sevier County cabin before I knew what I was doing, and the cabin grossed 41k last year and still lost money after the mortgage,…
Loss
Not a disaster by any measure but I keep turning over something my attorney said when I called him after the final K-1 landed. He said "you didn't lose money on the deal, you lost…
Discussion
I have been sitting on $180k that I want to put to work outside California for about eight months now. Not in another rental, not in another flip, in something managed by someone…
Discussion
Shreveport mixed use deal, the one I mentioned before with the ground floor retail. The LP agreement had pro rata participation language for any additional capital calls, and I re…
Discussion
I have seen this often enough that I now treat the hold period as a variable rather than a given, and the difference in what it does to a preferred return calculation is substanti…
Win
Closed out in February on a 7-story office building in Columbus that came in at 147 units. Original underwrite was 152 but the floor plate math changed after the structural report…