Loss
The fund presented deed conversions as an edge case, maybe 4 or 5 percent of the book. Twenty-three percent is not an edge case. I put in 200k out of Columbus in late 2021, and ri…
Discussion
A comment I keep returning to: a fund manager said the properties that redeem fastest are almost never the ones you would predict from the face of the certificate. A $1,200 lien o…
Happening Now
Got into a Florida-based lien fund in early 2023, $25k minimum, which was about the floor of what they'd take. It's redeeming now, 22 months in, at a 9.1% annualized return net to…
Happening Now
A fund will report its average winning bid rate, and occasionally its net yield, but I have not seen many that publish bid coverage, meaning how many competing bids they faced per…
Discussion
A tax lien certificate on a mobile home sitting on a rented lot has two problems running at once. The mobile home is personal property in most states, titled through the DMV or a…
Win
A deal worth studying: 80 certificates bought at a blended 2.1% bid rate across two Indiana counties, statutory rate 10%, holding period 26 months on the ones that redeemed. The e…
Discussion
A fund pitches a 16 percent statutory rate in a state where the statute allows it. What they do not put on page one is that winning bids at the actual county sale came in at 0.4 p…
Happening Now
I put capital into a lien fund about eight months ago, a mid-six-figure check, and I still do not have a clear picture of what "deployed" means on their side. They sent a welcome…
Win
So the block was small, 14 certificates across one county, roughly 60k deployed, and when it was all said and done over about 19 months I cleared around 6,400 net. The servicer to…
Discussion
New Jersey caps the interest rate at 18 percent. Winning bids at a competitive county auction last quarter were coming in around 0.25 percent, which means an LP reading the deck a…
Loss
A framing worth sitting with. Most capital side models for tax lien pools assume deed conversion is a backstop, maybe 4 to 6 percent of certificates, with those parcels priced con…
Story
I've been trying to work out if that number is the whole story or if it's cherry-picked from the softest auctions they entered. New Jersey statutory rate is 18%, so the spread bet…
Win
I wanted the pipeline before I wanted the yield, so I sized this to be survivable rather than meaningful. $92k, 38 certificates, two counties in one state, one servicer. Average c…
Loss
Portfolio was $290k across 90 certificates, nine counties in four states. The plan was geographic spread. What I actually built was nine separate procedural calendars and I tried…
Poll
I'm working through licensing on the service side and looking for something to build around. Three separate conversations in the last month with people buying liens at volume ende…
Loss
$9,400 total, my first attempt at this. The county had a list of certificates left over from earlier sales that you can buy directly at the stated rate, no auction, no bidding aga…
Loss
This is the tail risk I'd written down and priced at zero. 140 certificates, mostly small residential, spread over four counties. 131 redeemed and the book earned $61k of interest…
Poll
Reading through material on lien funds and the phrase that keeps appearing is government-backed. I've read it maybe a dozen times this week and I still can't tell what it covers.…
Loss
A useful case study: an investor registers in two counties, wires deposits, reads the rules for both, attends one auction in person and bids the other online, spending roughly six…
Discussion
I'm trying to work out where someone like me sells services into this rather than putting up capital. If an operation is bidding on a few hundred certificates a season, what parts…
Loss
Numbers first. 45k in, 46.1k out, 31 months. That's roughly 0.9% a year before I count the time I spent reading their updates. The stated target when I came in was a statutory rat…
Win
Say an investor puts 25k into a small lien fund and it returns 26.9k after fees fourteen months later. That is about 6.5% annualized, less than quoted certificate rates and worth…
Discussion
Two things I've read don't fit together. One says you can buy a tax lien for as little as $200, which makes it sound like the most accessible thing in real estate. The other descr…
Win
Income without a second job is the appeal of a lien fund over buying certificates directly, and a three year, $75k position with quarterly distributions is a useful case to study.…
Discussion
I have a deck from a lien buying operation quoting "up to 18% statutory" for one state, and then I went and pulled the actual results page from a county in that same state and the…
Happening Now
I have about 400k sitting in short term paper that I want moved into something secured by the end of the year. Tax liens keep coming back on my list because the return is set by s…
Happening Now
Take an investor bidding in two counties three weeks apart and coming out with 63 certificates. Average face around 1,840, total deployed 116k, rates between 6 and 14 depending on…
Discussion
I mentioned to a guy at a meetup that I was reading about buying liens across a few states and he said once you're doing it at any real volume you need a license, and possibly E&O…
Poll
Terms of sale language that limits a certificate holder's sole remedy, if a sale is later set aside or a certificate voided for a defect in the county's own process, to a refund o…
Poll
I'm 40 certificates in across six states and I picked those states specifically so I wouldn't be exposed to one housing market. Spent an evening going through why the owners were…
Poll
I'm reading this room from the outside, first rental still ahead of me, and the thing I can't resolve is how people decide the geographic shape before they've bought anything. The…
Discussion
Sizing a first allocation and the reserve line is where my model falls apart. Plan is roughly $4M across three or four states, average certificate around $4,400 face, so call it 9…
Loss
First real season of systematic deployment. $610k across 214 certificates, three counties in two states, one servicer handling the paperwork. Modeled 8.5% net to me. Actual came i…
Discussion
Start with a simple model, knowing it is too simple. Two hundred certificates, average face $2,200, statutory 16 percent, everything redeems inside 18 months. The spreadsheet retu…
Happening Now
Take a lien fund with roughly 60 million deployed across four states, reporting a weighted average bid rate of 12.4 percent for its last full vintage against a realized plus accru…
Happening Now
A scaled lien operation gets described sometimes as a bond ladder where the county does the collecting, and that framing is worth checking rather than just repeating. The mechanic…
Discussion
Trying to get $6M into certificates over roughly 18 months across three states. Two problems are eating the model and I can't tell which one is the real one. First, cash drag. The…
Loss
A structural pitfall worth understanding in tax lien fund investing is the difference between fees charged on committed capital versus invested capital, and how disciplined biddin…
Poll
I'm sizing a first real allocation and the bidding rule is the thing I can't settle. Two coherent ways to run it and they produce different bids on the same certificate. One: pric…
Poll
From the property management side, materials from lien funds describing themselves as fixed income substitutes tend to split into two halves that do not sit comfortably together.…