Discussion
I keep underwriting deals with a preferred equity structure and telling myself it functions like senior debt because I get paid before common, but the more I read the more I think…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a 240-unit workforce housing acquisition underwritten at $1,195 average in-place rent, with a value-add thesis projecting $1,380 at stabilization. The spons…
Discussion
Colocation leases measure occupancy three ways, power sold, cabinet count, and square footage, and the number a sponsor leads with is almost never the tightest one. A 50 MW facili…
Discussion
I've been watching this one carefully because I put $25,000 in and the sponsor underwrote a 5.1 exit cap. Sacramento multifamily is trading closer to 5.8 right now, and that's for…
Story
A 200-unit deal closes with a five-year hold in the deck, 7 percent pref, 70/30 split above an 8 percent IRR hurdle. Year four, the sponsor cannot hit the exit cap needed to prote…
Happening Now
Somebody sent me a deal last week, 228 units outside of Charlotte, and buried in the operating agreement was language that said the sponsor could restructure the distribution wate…
Loss
Someone walked me through a deal this week where the inn had posted a 68 percent occupancy rate and an ADR of $189 over the trailing twelve. On the surface that pencils. The GP wa…
Happening Now
A deal worth sitting with: a 48-unit value-add, GP raises LP equity at the typical terms, 8 percent preferred return, 70/30 split above that. Eighteen months in, the bridge lender…
Discussion
I've been watching Providence rents for about eight months now and the two-family market there keeps pulling me in. Median two-family list price in the Elmwood neighborhood was si…
Happening Now
Ran into this on a deal I'm looking at right now. The sponsor has three exits listed, all 2019 to 2022, and the deck shows IRRs and multiples for each. I asked for the closing sta…
Discussion
A GP bringing you a deal has already decided the waterfall. The question is whether you are reading the document that locks it in or taking their verbal summary of it. Those two t…
Happening Now
Got a deck on a 96 unit in Mesquite, Texas. T12 NOI looks reasonable until you pull the rent roll history and see occupancy was sitting at 54 percent through most of Q1 and Q2 las…
Discussion
A sponsor I have been studying recently structured a 48-month projected hold with a standard two-year extension option, and the base-case IRR in the deck assumed month 48 as the e…
Loss
Six quarters of on-time distributions sounds like a healthy deal until you ask where the cash came from. A reserve account funded at close, say $180,000 on a $1.2 million raise, c…
Discussion
A sponsor who says they have "500k in this deal" could mean cash from their own account, a deferred acquisition fee they converted to equity at close, or a loan from a related ent…
Story
Take a 12-unit bought at 1.1 million, with the sponsor collecting a 1 percent asset management fee on gross asset value annually. That is 11,000 a year drawn from LP capital regar…
Loss
The deal was a 64-unit value-add in a secondary market, five-year hold, 14 percent target IRR. Investors got back 80 cents on the dollar. The letter cited rising rates, constructi…
Discussion
Came up in a deal I am watching from the debt side. Original sponsor brought in a co-GP about eight months into a 36-month hold on a 48-unit value-add in suburban Columbus. Fine,…
Discussion
The clause shows up labeled something like "operational realignment right" and the notice period is ninety days. At that point the fifteen-year weighted average lease term on the…
Story
Been sitting with this for a few weeks on a deal I'm looking at, $2.8M raise for a 22-unit gut rehab in Tacoma, 18 month timeline, 14% preferred return target. The sponsor page ha…
Discussion
I've been reading PPMs for the last six weeks trying to understand what sponsors actually have to disclose, and this specific situation keeps coming up without a clear answer. Dea…
Discussion
Most of the attention in these threads goes to the gate percentage, the quarterly cap on redemptions as a share of outstanding NAV, but the suspension clause sits one paragraph ab…
Happening Now
I inherited a duplex in February and bought into a Sevier County cabin before I knew what I was doing, and the cabin grossed 41k last year and still lost money after the mortgage,…
Loss
Not a disaster by any measure but I keep turning over something my attorney said when I called him after the final K-1 landed. He said "you didn't lose money on the deal, you lost…
Happening Now
A 70/30 split above an 8 percent pref sounds standard, and for many deals it is. The question worth sitting with is what the 30 percent is actually taken against. Some waterfall s…
Happening Now
A 90 percent coverage ratio sounds like a fund paying nine dollars of real cash for every ten it distributes, which is fine until you ask what sits in the numerator. Most non-trad…
Discussion
I have seen this often enough that I now treat the hold period as a variable rather than a given, and the difference in what it does to a preferred return calculation is substanti…
Discussion
A 60-key limited service property in a secondary market might run at 68 percent occupancy and a $95 ADR, producing roughly $1.4 million in room revenue. A 90-key select service pr…
Discussion
I have been looking at a deal where the pref accrues monthly, distributions come quarterly, and the projected exit is in month 38. The sponsor is showing a 17.4 percent IRR on a 1…
Story
The mechanism worth studying is how the waterfall handled early exit: the IRR threshold was built for a 60 month hold, so a 24 month sale at an annualized IRR above the hurdle sti…
Happening Now
A deal I have been turning over lately involves a preferred equity position that converts to common interest if the sponsor misses two consecutive preferred distributions. The str…
Discussion
Trying to figure this out because I have $58k sitting in an SDIRA and a sponsor I've worked with before is offering LP interests in a 72-unit value-add in Tucson. The IRA would ow…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a 240-unit acquisition, $18 million in LP equity, 8 percent preferred return, five year hold. The PPM defined a capital event as any refinancing that return…
Loss
I was a co-GP on a 24-unit in Phoenix, closed September 2022, $1.8M raise. The operating partner handled LP communications and I assumed that meant something. First update went ou…
Discussion
He was reviewing a private REIT subscription for a client of his and he called me because he knows I have looked at a few of these. He said the operating agreement had a clause th…
Happening Now
A 1.75x EM over five years works out to roughly 11.8 percent annualized if you compound it straight. Getting from there to 15 percent IRR requires the model to front-load cash flo…
Story
A deal with a 7 percent pref and a 70/30 split sounds straightforward, but the calculation changes materially depending on whether the pref accrues on committed capital from day o…
Discussion
Most PPMs I read say the LP preferred return accrues from the date capital is funded. That sounds clean until you look at a deal where equity sits in escrow for six weeks before t…
Discussion
Looking at a deal right now where the distribution schedule says quarterly but the obligation language says "when cash flow permits." Those are different things and the gap betwee…
Happening Now
The Phoenix deal is a 2021 vintage refi play, 7% pref, 70/30 split, projected 5-year hold with a 1.7x EM on the deck. My slot would be $50k and I go completely hands off. The Albu…
Discussion
It's a hotel fund, so office is only about 18 percent of the total portfolio, but the amendment language around the extended hold period is doing something I can't quite parse. Th…
Discussion
A deal worth studying: a 72-unit value-add acquisition, $4.2M equity raise, 8 percent cumulative pref, 75/25 split above that, projected 18 percent IRR on a five-year hold. The nu…
Discussion
Looking at a possible participation in a small split outside Flagstaff, six lots, and when I ran the numbers on the hold period the carrying costs came out to roughly $38k against…
Happening Now
Picture an LP who spends three months reading the syndication docs on a 96 unit deal in Columbus, Ohio. $75k minimum, 7 percent pref, 70/30 split after that. The numbers look fine…
Happening Now
Spent two hours on this today. The sponsor looks fine on paper, March 2023 offering, $50M raise target, office/industrial mix in the Carolinas. Audited financials, yes, but I went…
Discussion
Passive investors in medical office funds generally expect the first few K-1s to carry meaningful depreciation. A cost segregation study in year one, with bonus depreciation flowi…
Discussion
I had modeled 1.5% going in, which would have been $43,500, but my attorney flagged a clause we negotiated at LOI that I had completely forgotten about, tied to the final purchase…
Loss
Got the update last week. Sponsor reappraised at $28.4M, bought in at a valuation implying closer to $47M two years ago. Tucson and Scottsdale vintage I've looked at since are pri…
Discussion
Accountant flagged it immediately, said California doesn't conform to bonus depreciation the way federal does, so the loss I was counting on for federal purposes just... Doesn't e…
Discussion
Conventional wisdom in my circle was that any retail component in a residential deal drags the whole thing down, too much vacancy risk, too much TI exposure, and lenders who price…
Happening Now
Here is a comparison worth working through, because the same 125k can go two very different places. The Akron triplex is listed at 498k, two units rented at 925 and 975, third uni…
Discussion
Take a 144 bed property near a mid size state school where a 50k LP position goes in and the projections put first year distributions around month 10. Month 11 arrives and nothing…
Story
So I've been circling this for about eight months. I'm not an operator, I have never run a campground, never bought a park outright. What I have done is read probably forty decks…
Happening Now
Consider a passive LP who owns a quarter of a multifamily building in Columbus and has never set foot in it, which means relying heavily on what people say. The operating partner…
Happening Now
The answer keeps moving depending on what you assume the final sale price is, which is most of the lesson in this comparison. Deal A is a 48-unit in Huntsville, $50k minimum, 7 pe…
Happening Now
That is the number worth stopping on, ahead of the IRR projection and ahead of the zone location. Sponsor fee 1.5 percent, asset management 1.25 percent, fund admin 0.6 percent, a…
Happening Now
A question a sharp CPA will raise when reviewing syndication K-1s is where the interest actually lands when a deal is structured as a wrap. The payor's interest deduction and the…
Loss
Conventional thinking has been that passive exposure here means steady distributions, maybe 6 to 7% cash on cash, and a sponsor team that keeps you informed. Consider a case. An L…
Story
Consider a passive LP holding a quarter of a 2001 suburban office building in Tempe, about 41,000 square feet, who has never been inside it. Eight months earlier the GP flagged on…
Discussion
Looking at my first LP deal instead of another flip, and the summary page has three numbers stacked on top of each other. 15% IRR, 1.8x equity multiple, 8% average cash-on-cash. O…